Cayuga, Ontario, Canada
As of August 12, 2026, the median asking price in Cayuga is $649,900, across 27 active MLS® listings.
Those listings have been on the market an average of 101 days.
5 new listings came to market in Cayuga in the last 30 days.
Asking prices work out to about $400 per square foot, based on the 17 listings that report floor area.
Detached homes in Cayuga are listed at an average of $679,388 across 16 active listings.
Grand River calm, Talbot Street soul
Cayuga’s core neighbourhood is the kind of small-town Ontario that still feels oriented around a main street and a riverbank. Talbot Street’s historic downtown sets the tone—brick façades, familiar storefronts, and a steady daily rhythm—while the Grand River frames the community with wide skies, seasonal colour, and an easy, outdoorsy pace.
Housing here reads like a local timeline: older character homes with deep lots, tidy post-war bungalows, and detached properties that have been cared for across generations. Newer infill shows up in pockets rather than waves, and rentals tend to be smaller-scale—duplexes and low-rise multi-units—so the streetscape stays predominantly low-rise and residential. With a walk score around 64, errands and coffee runs are comfortably doable near the core, while most residents still rely on a car for regional commuting and big-box shopping.
The market typically behaves more like a stable small town than a fast-flipping city: lower turnover, more neighbour-to-neighbour familiarity, and pricing that tends to move in steadier steps. Buyers are often looking for space and livability—yards, basements, and garages—while sellers benefit from limited inventory and strong local attachment. It’s a neighbourhood that rewards patience and long-term thinking, where “value” is as much about community roots and river-town character as it is about square footage.
Cayuga’s market currently has 29 active listings with a median asking price of $649,838 and an average of $411 per square foot, giving buyers a clear sense of current pricing and value. Homes are taking an average of 99 days to sell and only 4 new listings have come on in the past 30 days, pointing to a slower-moving environment where well-priced properties stand out and investors may find room to negotiate on longer-sitting listings.
Walk Score 64 · Bike Score 52
The median asking price in Cayuga is $649,900, across 27 active MLS® listings as of August 12, 2026. The average asking price is $608,061. These are list prices on homes currently for sale, not sale prices.
There are 27 active MLS® listings in Cayuga as of August 12, 2026. 5 of them came to market in the last 30 days.
Homes currently listed in Cayuga have been on the market an average of 101 days as of August 12, 2026. This measures how long active listings have been available so far, not how long they take to sell.
Of the 27 homes currently listed in Cayuga, 59% detached houses, 15% vacant land, 11% townhouses, 7% duplexes.
Cayuga has a Walk Score of 64 out of 100, which Walk Score classifies as Somewhat Walkable — some errands can be accomplished on foot. Bike Score is 52.